THE SITUATION

Appraisal Came In Below the List Price

I represented the seller of a home that received multiple offers. The seller accepted the highest offer, approximately $50,000 over asking price. The buyer was obtaining mortgage financing, so the property needed to appraise at or near the contract price.

As part of my normal process, I met the appraiser and provided a sealed information packet containing:

Listing information
Fully executed Purchase & Sale Agreement
Relevant recent comparable sales
Market-supported adjustments for square footage, bedrooms, bathrooms, garage spaces, lot characteristics, and condition
Important facts not readily available in public records, when relevant and factual

THE CHALLENGE

Below List Pice Offer

The appraisal came in below the List Price. Remember the accepted Offer was $50,000 above the List Price.

After reviewing the report, I believed the issue was not a lack of market support, but the comparable sales selected. The appraiser was not local to the area, used a different style home as one comparable, and included another property located in a neighborhood impacted by a gun club and high-tension power lines. Better local comparables were available but were not used.

The buyer requested a price reduction based on the appraisal. We requested a reconsideration of value and a new appraisal, citing the weak comparable selection, but the buyer declined. The transaction was terminated.

Conversions increased

In 2 months

THE OUTCOME

300% increase in conversion rate in just 2 months

Rather than continue negotiating a deal that no longer worked, we moved to the next buyer from the original multiple-offer situation.

That buyer also required financing.

This time:

- A new appraisal was completed.
- The property appraised at the contract price.
- The sale closed successfully at nearly the same price as the first contract.

The experience also improved my appraisal process.

I had always provided the necessary information, but I changed how I presented it.

Today, I summarize comparable sales in the same adjustment format commonly used by appraisers, making it easier to review the data and understand the rationale behind the contract price.

Since making that change, I have not experienced another appraisal issue caused by weak comparable selection.

One important caveat:

If a buyer offers substantially more than the market supports, no agent or appraiser can legitimately create value that isn't there.

Get your free guide

KEY TAKE AWAYS

A listing agent's role is not to tell an appraiser what a property is worth.

It is to ensure the appraiser has complete, relevant, and accurate market information.

When appraisal issues arise, experience matters:

Recognizing when an appraisal should be challenged.
Presenting market data in a format appraisers can quickly evaluate.
Knowing when it's better to move to the next qualified buyer.
Keeping the seller's long-term goals in focus.

A successful transaction isn't just about negotiating the best offer—it's about navigating every step required to get to the closing table.

How we increased conversions 300% for Digital Beaver Inc

Ipsum dolor curabitur arcu erat, accumsan id imperdiet, porttitor at sem. Vestibulum ac lorem ipsumdiam sit amet.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Curabitur urna nunc, bibendum ac egestas in, porta eu nulla. Nulla facilisi. Vivamus et egestas ligula. Vivamus pretium nulla velit, euismod efficitur metus ultricies non. Nullam id augue et enim lobortis tristique quis ut augue. Etiam vitae dolor justo. Sed quis consequat massa. .

Vivamus magna
Lacinia eget

Curabitur convallis tortor ut lectus pretium, a fermentum arcu tempor. Proin posuere massa at dui porttitor accumsan. Curabitur eleifend est in tellus tempor pulvinar. Nullam pellentesque, lacus quis aliquam faucibus, nibh risus lobortis justo, eget porttitor metus ligula vel magna. Sed cursus sem ac vestibulum tincidunt.

Lorem ipsum
Dolor tellus

Donec ultrices fringilla quam non pharetra. Praesent feugiat metus id ligula commodo, a facilisis quam rhoncus. Phasellus fringilla mi sit amet lacinia cursus. Integer vestibulum tincidunt ipsum, sit amet sodales ex vestibulum quis. Nam mollis ornare augue, et iaculis odio pulvinar.

Feugiat Lacinia
Westibulum nam

More case studies